The impulse and ability to create art is one of the highlights of being human. It’s a key quality that sets us apart from the animal world, one that makes life more meaningful and enjoyable. While there are artistic skills that make it easier for people to bring their imaginations into the visible, tangible world, art doesn’t abide by any hard and fast rules. Especially kids’ art. Especially young kids’ art.
There is no right or wrong in art, only expression and interpretation. That’s the beauty of it. Unlike working with numbers and spreadsheets and data, there is no correct answer and no one way to arrive at the proper destination. As the famous quote from Dead Poet’s Society goes, “Medicine, law, business, engineering, these are noble pursuits and necessary to sustain life. But poetry, beauty, romance, love, these are what we stay alive for.”
That’s why one mom was furious when her 6-year-old’s art teacher told the girl her painting was “wrong.”
Gemma Leighton, mother of 6-year-old Edie, shared her daughter’s painting on Twitter with a request for support. Edie created the painting in an after school art club, and her art teacher told her she did it wrong.
“You can’t do art wrong!” wrote Leighton. “She was so upset as art is her favourite thing to do.”
Now, we don’t know exactly what the teacher said to Edie, or why, but if a 6-year-old comes home upset and feeling like there’s something wrong with their art, the teacher did something wrong. Full stop. Six-year-olds are just beginning to learn about technique, and encouragement is the most vital thing a teacher can offer a budding artist.
The internet rightfully pounced to Edie’s defense, and the responses are incredibly heartwarming.
Many people shared how hurt they were as children when a teacher told them something was wrong with their art—and that they were wrong. Knowing that grown-ups had experienced the same kinds of unnecessary criticism as kids and realized that it was wrong can help Edie feel confident that her painting is not “wrong.”
Others pointed out the famous artists that her painting reminded them of. Seeing how her own painting reflects some of the style and color choices of professional artists can help Edie see the spark of genius in her own artwork.
Songwriter Kimya Dawson, most famous for her songs in the movie Juno, shared that a middle school English teacher had told her to stop writing poems because they were “too juvenile.”
“I never stopped though and making rhyming poems has been my career for over 20 years!” Dawson wrote in a Reply. “Your painting is perfect! Keep it up! Don’t worry what anyone else thinks.”
Professional artists chimed in with words of encouragement, pointing out that Edie’s use of perspective and expressionism were quite impressive for her age.
“The only ‘wrong’ is not making art that speaks from your heart,” wrote an artist who goes by @Artsy on Twitter. “When she expresses her passion, her vision of her world, her personal reactions to what she sees and feels, she’ll never be ‘wrong.'”
Now that’s how it’s done! Experts say that not just general encouragement, but pointing out specific things in a child’s work that are the building blocks of art and literacy are key to building their self-esteem. In fact, the creative process in and of itself is great at building a child’s self-esteem! It allows them to practice independence and feel immense pride at their finished product, no matter what anyone thinks it looks like. Really the only way to turn art into a negative thing for a child is to criticize it.
Even KISS guitarist Paul Stanley offered Edie words of encouragement.
Judging technique can come later. Way later. For now, just let kids create. Photo with Bahar Ghis
“Your art is AWESOME!!!” he wrote.
“There is no such thing as doing art ‘wrong.’ There are only teachers who are wrong!!! Your art shows amazing freedom and spirit. How can that be ‘wrong’?!?! Keep doing EXACTLY what you are doing. I LOVE it!!!”
Imagine being a heartbroken 6-year-old who has been told by a teacher that her art was wrong, and then seeing a flood of thousands of supportive comments from people who looked at the same piece of art and told you what they loved about it. This is how social media should be used. To lift people up, to encourage and inspire, to share beauty and creativity.
After the outpouring, Leighton created a new Twitter account called Edie’s Art for people to share kids’ artwork, and gracious, it’s a delight to peruse.
There’s nothing more pure, more colorful, more full of life than art that came from a child’s imagination. They may not have the technical skills to perfectly create what they envision in their minds or what they’re looking at for inspiration, but that’s part of what makes it so beautiful. They aren’t self-conscious enough yet to hold back, and their art comes from a place of confidence and acceptance of their own abilities—that is, until some adult comes along and squashes their artistic spirit.
One of my favorite things as a parent has been watching my kids’ artistic expressions evolve as they’ve grown, and I’ve loved their artwork at every stage. And not just because I’m their mom, but because kid creations are the best reminder of how natural the human impulse to create really is, and how beautiful it is when we share that impulse without fear or doubt.
As for Edie, she didn’t let that early criticism keep her down. The original story happened about four years ago, and today Evie continues to pursue art. Her mom still occasionally shares the odd piece or two on Twitter/X, and even posted a fun stop-motion video Evie created using one of her stuffed animals. Clearly, her creative spirit could not be suppressed so easily.
“Edie is now immersed in the digital art world and still creates wonderful things every day Keep creating little artists,” her mom shared in a recent update on X.
Keep painting, Edie, and all you kiddos out there. Don’t let one person’s opinion—even a teacher’s—hold you back.
This article originally appeared four years ago. It has been updated.
About The Author
